I bought Blue Bell Pints of ice cream because they were on sale for $1.98. Here is an update and review of the flavors.

Dutch Chocolate 10/10 This was such an amazing flavor and such a rich and creamy chocolate. I could not stop eating it. It actually reminded me of Culver’s chocolate ice cream, it’s so good!

Homemade Vanilla 9.5/10 Absolutely amazing, I tried it last night for the first time and was blown away. It’s so silky and creamy and one of the best flavors, I still can’t believe plain vanilla can be that good, now I understand all the hype! Trust me try the plain vanilla flavor, people are correct to have it as their favorite. This would have been my #1 but then I tried chocolate so it’s at #2.

Cookie Two Step 8.5/10 Really delicious, has cookie and cookie dough pieces. The cookies n cream ice cream I had earlier was okay so the cookies n dough is what elevated it to the next level.

Cookies n Cream 7/10 It’s cookies n cream ice cream so how can you possibly not like it, ya know? But for me after trying all the other flavors this was just meh. I wouldn’t kick it out of bed, but would go for other options if available.

Butter Crunch 5/10 This was the first flavor I tried from the bunch and it was instantly a no. It’s just too much going on, too many pieces and super heavy on peanut butter flavor. It’s just not for me, I’m sure there are a lot of people who love peanut butter and love this flavor. Again, it’s ice cream but for this one I wouldn’t kick it definitely kick it out of bed, sorry Blue Bell.

All in all for the price trying all the flavors was awesome. At least now I know that when it comes to BlueBell their plain flavor ice cream is my favorite. Obviously the texture changes when you add mix-ins but I feel like their vanilla doesn’t taste the same in the pints of the other flavors. Idk maybe it’s just me. I’m not sure if they have cookie dough because I would probably really like that.