Just beat AW2 and feel lost

Alan Wake 2 is basically the first game I have gotten through in probably a year and now I'm finding it hard to get into anything else - particularly the story was just too engrossing and now nothing else really compares. I'm trying to get into other games, and I tried Control but it hasn't grabbed me.

Does anyone have a game like this that gives a similar vibe? Gameplay and story wise, but particularly story.

EDIT: Thanks for all the suggestions. I did actually buy Silent Hill 2 a couple weeks ago but never got into it because been busy but will give it a try.

I've also since got back into Control and sunk 9 hours since the initial post - enjoying it a lot more than I was even if it's not the exact same. Plan to hopefully get the platinum soon